Southwest shareholders needn’t act like passengers
Corrects structure of Elliott’s ownership stake in paragraph 2. The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
By Jeffrey Goldfarb
NEW YORK, Aug 14 (Reuters Breakingviews) -Airplane passengers tolerate a lot of discomfort because of their limited choices. Shareholders often suffer similarly even though they’re not equally constrained. Southwest Airlines LUV.N, the discount carrier that Elliot Investment Management has turned into a battlefield, shows it doesn’t have to be that way.
The rabble-rousing hedge fund firm on Tuesday threatened to nominate 10 candidates, including the former chief executives of Air Canada AC.TO and Virgin America, to Southwest’s 15-person board. With an 8% beneficial ownership stake – 11% after adding other securities – in the $15 billion company, Elliott is close to having the requisite 10% to convene a special meeting of shareholders to advance its agenda, which ultimately involves ousting boss Robert Jordan. Southwest effectively dug in its heels, expressing confidence in its leadership and strategic plan.
Elliott’s timing is curious. It started its public campaign in June, shortly after shareholders enthusiastically elected Southwest’s proposed slate of board members, despite the airline’s shrinking operating profit margin and huge loss in market value. Such sheep-like behavior is all too common. Through mid-July, U.S. director nominees on average had received 95.3% of the ballot, 60 basis points higher than in 2023, according to consultancy Semler Brossy.
Look closer, however, and there are signs of frustration. More than a fifth of shareholders voted against Southwest’s executive pay plans, even though advisory firm Institutional Shareholder Services backed them. Moreover, eight out of 10 analysts rate the company either a “hold” or a “sell,” according to Visible Alpha, in a break with the typical deference to management that brokers provide.
Jordan has other reasons to worry too. Elliott hasn’t run a U.S. proxy battle since 2017, a sign that the many companies it targets are usually unnerved enough to make concessions. The CEOs of Starbucks SBUX.O, Johnson Controls International JCI.N and Crown Castle CCI.N also recently raised the white flag following the activist fund manager’s arrival on the scene.
On this occasion, shareholders may have to force the issue themselves if they want to shake things up. It’s a tall order. To oust a board member mid-term requires 50% support from all outstanding shares, as opposed to the mere plurality needed to win election at an annual meeting. Southwest is due to present its own plans for reviving its stock in September. Then shareholders can decide if they want to exert more influence than flyers typically do.
Follow @jgfarb on X
CONTEXT NEWS
Elliott Investment Management said on Aug. 13 that it plans to nominate 10 candidates for the board of Southwest Airlines in further pursuit of its aim to shake up the carrier.
Southwest responded on Aug. 14 that it had previously tried to engage with the activist investment firm, including arranging a meeting for early September. The company, which is being advised by Bank of America and Morgan Stanley, also said it is confident it has the right leadership team in place.
Elliott on June 10 disclosed an 11% stake in Southwest and urged changes to senior leadership as well as the board, currently made up of 15 directors.
The fund manager’s director candidates include former Ryanair Deputy CEO Michael Cawley, former Virgin America CEO David Cush and former Air Canada CEO Robert Milton.
Graphic: Southwest shareholders expressed only some displeasure https://reut.rs/4ctlkGv
Editing by John Foley and Sharon Lam
الأصول ذات الصلة
آخر الأخبار
إخلاء المسؤولية: تتيح كيانات XM Group خدمة تنفيذية فقط والدخول إلى منصة تداولنا عبر الإنترنت، مما يسمح للشخص بمشاهدة و/أو استخدام المحتوى المتاح على موقع الويب أو عن طريقه، وهذا المحتوى لا يراد به التغيير أو التوسع عن ذلك. يخضع هذا الدخول والاستخدام دائماً لما يلي: (1) الشروط والأحكام؛ (2) تحذيرات المخاطر؛ (3) إخلاء المسؤولية الكامل. لذلك يُقدم هذا المحتوى على أنه ليس أكثر من معلومات عامة. تحديداً، يرجى الانتباه إلى أن المحتوى المتاح على منصة تداولنا عبر الإنترنت ليس طلباً أو عرضاً لدخول أي معاملات في الأسواق المالية. التداول في أي سوق مالي به مخاطرة عالية برأس مالك.
جميع المواد المنشورة على منصة تداولنا مخصصة للأغراض التعليمية/المعلوماتية فقط ولا تحتوي - ولا ينبغي اعتبار أنها تحتوي - على نصائح أو توصيات مالية أو ضريبية أو تجارية، أو سجلاً لأسعار تداولنا، أو عرضاً أو طلباً لأي معاملة في أي صكوك مالية أو عروض ترويجية مالية لا داعي لها.
أي محتوى تابع للغير بالإضافة إلى المحتوى الذي أعدته XM، مثل الآراء، والأخبار، والأبحاث، والتحليلات والأسعار وغيرها من المعلومات أو روابط مواقع تابعة للغير وواردة في هذا الموقع تُقدم لك "كما هي"، كتعليق عام على السوق ولا تعتبر نصيحة استثمارية. يجب ألا يُفسر أي محتوى على أنه بحث استثماري، وأن تلاحظ وتقبل أن المحتوى غير مُعدٍ وفقاً للمتطلبات القانونية المصممة لتعزيز استقلالية البحث الاستثماري، وبالتالي، فهو بمثابة تواصل تسويقي بموجب القوانين واللوائح ذات الصلة. فضلاً تأكد من أنك قد قرأت وفهمت الإخطار بالبحوث الاستثمارية غير المستقلة والتحذير من مخاطر المعلومات السابقة، والذي يمكنك الاطلاع عليه هنا.
